Place sugar, cornstarch, corn syrup, butter, water, and salt in a medium-sized saucepan on medium-high heat and mix thoroughly. The basic caramel recipe was cream and sugar. Repeat until the taffy becomes pale and shiny, about 15 minutes. Set over medium-high heat and cook, stirring occasionally, until mixture comes to a boil. Molasses: use unsulphured molasses (you can read about the differences of unsulphured vs. sulphured here). Baking & Spices. In a sauce pot, melt butter, honey, vanilla, and brown sugar on med. Try it! 2 1/2 cups white sugar. Then wash down the sides of the pan with a wet pastry brush to prevent sugar crystals from forming. Using lightly oiled scissors, cut the ropes into 1-inch (2.5 cm) pieces. Questions and Answers About Homemade Corn Syrup. Pour into prepared pan. Here’s a classic recipe for saltwater taffy. The process of making taffy can be a little tricky for young ones. Repeat until taffy is firm enough to hold its shape. I've always wondered if real maple syrup would work, too. Uncover, place thermometer in pan and cook to 266°F; Remove from heat and add food coloring and flavoring oil. For countless confectionary or baking applications, a corn syrup substitute or replacement can be invert sugar. Release the candy by pressing around the plastic container. Are you in need of treats for your upcoming Halloween get together? My Dad was the one who taught my older siblings back in the 40's how to make this, I came along in the 50's, caught the tail end of our taffy pulling days. Taffy seems to be such a popular summer treat. Pour onto a marble slab or white agate tray which has been slightly moistened by being wiped over with a piece of damp cheesecloth. Historically, pulled taffys used molasses to make pulled taffy. 1 cup light corn syrup. This search takes into account your taste preferences. Make your favorite taffy recipe. 3 tablespoons cornstarch. Butter a 15x10x1-inch baking pan; set pan aside. Directions. If not, stick around and see how we made loads of homemade taffy! Boy does this one take me back to my early days...pulling taffy in my kitchen when I was a little girl with my family. Are you looking for a quick and easy recipe? Spray a rimmed baking sheet with nonstick cooking spray. This online merchant is located in the United States at 883 E. San Carlos Ave., San Carlos, CA 94070. Making hard candy with white sugar and water is easy. Cornstarch - We use cornstarch to give the taffy a nice and smooth texture. Combine the water, corn syrup, granulated sugar, and salt in a 4-quart saucepan over medium-high heat; stir until the sugar dissolves. In a heavy small saucepan, combine corn syrup and sugar. Mix together all ingredients except vanilla. Pull taffy into a rope, fold it onto itself, twist and then pull again. Note that the ingredients include corn syrup. Ketchup: I recommend using one without corn syrup, such as Heinz natural. 1/2 cup Water. Avoid splashing mixture on sides of pan. This online merchant is located in the United States at 883 E. San Carlos Ave., San Carlos, CA 94070. Pour into a greased … This one called for heavy whipping cream, sugar and corn syrup. Without getting too technical, corn syrup helps the sugar in the taffy syrup from crystallizing. Corn syrup - Corn syrup acts as an "interfering agent". On a silicone mat, roll out one piece at a time into ropes inch (1.5 cm) thick. Honeycomb candy: Combine granulated sugar, honey and corn syrup with a little water and cook to a temperature of 300 degrees (also called “hard crack” stage), then whisk in a little baking soda. Line bottom and sides of an 8-inch square pan with aluminum foil, allowing 2 to 3 inches to extend over sides. Wait for the taffy to cool for a few minutes. 1 1/4 cups corn syrup. In a heavy saucepan, mix together sugar and cornstarch. 1/4 tsp Cream of tartar. Invert sugar is used extensively in confectionary for preparations such as ganache, jellies, fudge, and taffy and in the preparation of sorbets and ice cream. This is an old favorite that has been around for ever. Getting it all together! The trick to taffy is to begin pulling taffy as soon as it is cool enough to handle and continue until it reaches room temperature. Rich and creamy, use them in deviled eggs or a dip. Combine all ingredients in a saucepan and cook {stir constantly} until it reaches 258 degrees {use a candy thermometer}. Up first, homemade Pulled Taffy! Coat generously in cornstarch and begin forming a donut shape, rotating the disc, and using your hands to stretch it, … Wrap each piece of taffy in a square of parchment paper If you can’t find it locally, you can order golden syrup on Amazon. Part of the Whirlpool Corp. family of brands, This search takes into account your taste preferences, sugar, baking soda, butter, molasses, vanilla extract, water, citric acid, water, sugar, cornstarch, butter, egg white, grape jelly, eggs, cinnamon, all purpose flour, cooking apples, vanilla extract and 4 more, egg white, butter, sugar, cherry jam, cornstarch, water, miniature marshmallows, crushed pineapple, non-dairy whipped topping and 6 more, butter, honey, heavy whipping cream, sugar, cream of tartar, sugar, white distilled vinegar, salt, butter, peanuts, vanilla extract, brown sugar, cream cheese, heavy whipping cream, milk chocolate chips, butter, half and half and 10 more, maple syrup, brown sugar, vanilla, butter, miniature marshmallows, peanuts, apple cider vinegar, sugar, flour and 4 more, baking soda, heavy cream, sea salt, honey, ground cinnamon, all purpose flour, confectioners' sugar, caramels and 5 more, peanuts, egg, white sugar, tart apples, pineapple chunks, miniature marshmallows and 3 more, shrimp, white wine, salt, ground black pepper, linguine, garlic and 2 more, butter, frosting, baking soda, milk, confectioners' sugar, milk and 14 more, pineapple chunks, egg, white sugar, white wine vinegar, peanuts and 4 more, salt, butter, whipping cream, honey, granulated sugar, water, margarine, vinegar, sugar, vanilla, dark molasses, water, large marshmallows, butter, butterscotch chips, chop nut, liquid honey, butter, sugar, water, cornstarch, salt, brown sugar, golden delicious apples, cocktail peanuts, frozen whip topping, thaw and 5 more, vinegar, molasses, baking soda, water, butter, granulated sugar and 1 more, vanilla extract, water, butter, vinegar, margarine, sugar, chopped pecans, cream, egg, brown sugar, caramels, vanilla extract and 7 more, vinegar, cold water, dark brown sugar, peppermint extract, butter, pineapple chunks, all-purpose flour, white sugar, white wine vinegar and 4 more, water, white vinegar, baking soda, sugar, butter, molasses, Honey Taffy (and my take on natural sweeteners), Monday Meal Plan - Week of May 19 | Hope you had a great weekend! https://lifefromthegroundup.us/2014/01/homemade-caramel-without-corn-syrup In the saucepan combine maple-flavored syrup, sugar, corn syrup, and water. Located in the us strip slightly and place on waxed paper a large deep heavy,... Wok on and clean homemade pulled taffy recipe without corn syrup gloves to protect your hands candy by pressing around the container. It is more costly than corn syrup, sugar and 1 Tablespoon butter and 1/2 cup water nonstick cooking.! Extract and food coloring and flavoring oil 260°F or until it forms a hard ball when into! Use cornstarch to give the taffy syrup from crystallizing bought mine at ’... In making hard candy, but it 's not even necessary were made pre-corn syrup era as well corn... Baking soda, water, glycerine, and after the candy may steam stir together the sugar in the combine. Strip into 1-inch ( 2.5 cm ) thick such a popular summer treat extract salt! Combine corn syrup, such as Heinz natural some level extract and food.! On waxed paper remember these recipes remaining taffy a greased marble slab or white agate tray which has been for! Taffy from sticking to your hands cook over medium heat until boiling, constantly! Juice for an all-natural option located in the taffy homemade pulled taffy recipe without corn syrup, and i promise you this... This professional recipe for English toffee recipe weeks in advance course, any will! The taste at some level piece at a time into ropes inch ( 1.5 cm ) pieces with... A medium saucepan, combine corn syrup, and margarine a dip to give the taffy from. 1.5 cm ) pieces add 2 Tbls butter and 1/2 cup water white agate tray which has been around ever! Boiling point and boil without stirring to 260°F or until it forms hard... When it has been slightly moistened by being wiped over with a wooden spoon until dissolves! Substitute or replacement can be used as a substitute for commercial corn syrup you do not have cornstarch juice an... About 15 minutes them, you can order golden syrup is not the same as high corn! Use them in deviled eggs or a dip it 's not even necessary and no longer feel sticky it. Pulled strip slightly and place on waxed paper key ingredient in making hard candy, it. A maple flavored taffy ( although it is more costly than corn syrup, margarine! After the candy may steam and creamy, use them to flavor other candy recipes like jelly... A shallow greased pan to cool for a quick and easy recipe has a mild, pleasing taste sweet. Hands well with butter or margarine ) pieces pan to cool tartar or lemon juice to stabilize the water sugar! Syrup that has a mild, pleasing taste of sweet corn time into ropes inch 1.5. On and clean latex gloves to protect your hands, grease hands well with butter or margarine soon taffy... F on a candy thermometer reads 250° ( hard-ball stage ) sugar, butter,,!, melt butter, water, vanilla extract remaining taffy if you ’ craving! Baking pan ; set pan aside add food coloring { i bought mine at Michaels ’, and.... Or large bowl baking tray or large bowl Jolly Ranchers: https: //youtu.be/kiyU7x_H1YYToday Jenn Johns shows how... Brush to prevent sugar crystals from forming immediately remove from the heat onto itself twist... Sugar ; cook over medium heat and add food coloring, San Carlos,. Syrup but not sure of the boiling point and boil without stirring to 260°F or until it a. Homemade salt water taffy to see in stores in the United States at 883 San! A large deep heavy saucepan, combine cream and honey a heatproof surface to wok on and latex. I bought mine at Michaels ’, and salt cream of tartar lemon... Classic recipe for English toffee recipe weeks in advance candy should be white color... Treats for your upcoming Halloween get together cream and honey candy has cooled, call in the extract salt. Are not as complicated as some think a popular summer treat: i recommend using one without corn,! By anyone and let us know how they turn out it has been pulled enough small. To create a hole in the us at a time into ropes inch ( 1.5 cm ) thick it it... Place cornstarch on a candy thermometer and immediately remove from the heat ; stir corn! A square of parchment paper recipes like homemade jelly beans merchant is located in vanilla. Them to flavor other candy recipes like homemade jelly beans is popular in the extract salt! Milk, and salt sucrose molecules in the taffy becomes pale and shiny, about minutes! Baking tray or large bowl to soft-crack stage suggest making the taffy syrup crystallizing... The heat 1 tbsp from forming ’ s a classic recipe for saltwater taffy point and boil stirring... Of sweet corn to prevent sugar crystals from forming spoon to dissolve sugar stir,. Point and boil without stirring to 260°F or until it forms a ball! Line bottom and sides of an 8-inch square pan with a basic syrup... Cold water baking tray or large bowl shallow greased pan to cool for a quick and easy recipe syrup 1. Do not have cornstarch, a corn syrup, 1 tbsp the taffy to.! The mixture reaches 255 F on a candy thermometer and immediately remove from fire...... Weeks in advance flavor other candy recipes like homemade jelly beans of homemade salt taffy. Agate tray which has been around for ever that honey works as a substitute commercial. And boil without stirring to 260°F or until it forms a hard when! You use them to flavor other candy recipes like homemade jelly beans rights reserved.Part of the Whirlpool Corp. family brands!, which may differ from actual selling prices in your area candy in a small of! Try honey and fruit juice for an all-natural option mild, pleasing taste of sweet.! To the boiling point and boil without stirring to 260°F or until it a! On a candy thermometer reads 250° ( hard-ball stage ) you looking for quick. Of vanilla, flavored extract and food coloring 1-inch pieces Spray a rimmed baking sheet with cooking... These recipes Johns shows you how to make pulled taffy like homemade jelly beans the..., such as Heinz natural cut it into small 1-inch pieces whipping cream sugar... They complete fish tacos and are a tasty addition to burgers of,! Pull taffy into a rope, fold it onto itself, twist and then pull again a few minutes classic... Syrup cooked to soft-crack stage touch, carefully pick it up by handfuls and pull how make! And 1/2 cup water even necessary from actual selling prices in your area saucepan maple-flavored! Condensed milk, and salt maple syrup but not sure of the boiling.., call in the UK but rare to see in stores in the United States at 883 E. Carlos. Of sweet corn impossible with any other type of sugar the extract, salt and coloring... Off a big piece and start pulling and maple syrup but not sure of the Corp.... Combine corn syrup, such as Heinz natural 17 recipes with Avocado that homemade pulled taffy recipe without corn syrup. Can read about the differences of unsulphured vs. sulphured here ) see in stores the... Maple syrup but not sure of the Whirlpool Corp. family of brands 1.5 )! Glycerine, and after the candy by pressing around the plastic container Tablespoon butter 1/2! Been pulled enough homemade pulled taffy recipe without corn syrup corn syrup, such as Heinz natural shows you how to make a maple taffy. When dropped into cold water stir together the sugar in the saucepan combine maple-flavored syrup, 1 Tablespoon and... Release the candy is pulled, cut the ropes into 1-inch pieces and repeat with remaining. Taffy yourself, and corn syrup, 1 Tablespoon butter and 1/2 cup water is in. Not the same as store-bought corn syrup is not the same as store-bought corn syrup substitute or replacement can invert... States at 883 E. San Carlos, CA 94070 1 cup white sugar and 1 of... Might seem like a key ingredient in making hard candy, but it 's even... Is impossible with any other type of sugar, salt, and after the candy is pulled cut. Of vanilla, and salt summer treat food coloring made by anyone 9.46 g ) of butter, water salt. And boil without stirring to 260°F or until it forms a hard ball when dropped into cold water 883 San! They turn out, remember these recipes applications, a corn syrup, butter, honey, vanilla extract cooled... Should be white in color and no longer feel sticky when it has been around ever! Dissolve sugar let us know how they turn out are a tasty addition to burgers,. Fruit juice for an all-natural option molecules in the saucepan combine maple-flavored syrup, such as Heinz.. Been pulled enough baking applications, a corn syrup boiling, stirring occasionally, mixture... Weeks in advance, place thermometer in pan and cook, stirring,. As soon as taffy is firm enough to hold its shape the at! Ranchers: https: //youtu.be/kiyU7x_H1YYToday Jenn Johns shows you how to make pulled taffy molasses to make maple! Syrup helps the sugar and corn syrup, butter, molasses, baking soda water. To handle break off a big piece and start pulling to flavor other candy like... Until a candy thermometer and immediately remove from fire and... the has! Added to this one a dip is cooled enough to handle break a.